[情報] 五位球團人士評皇家光芒交易

http://tinyurl.com/ac85auz If the five email responses I received from baseball executives late Sunday night are any indication, the reaction within the baseball industry is more nuanced. A National League general manager called the deal "bold on both sides," but liked it more from Kansas City's end. An AL talent evaluator also favored the Royals, in part because he suspects Myers might not be as good as the hype. Two other personnel people were decidedly pro-Tampa Bay. "The Royals got owned on this one," said an NL executive, who marveled at Friedman's huge haul of young talent. Another National League talent evaluator praised Moore for his chutzpah, but not so much for his baseball judgment. "My initial view was basic shock that Dayton did this," the evaluator said, "especially with so much pitching on the free-agent market. But they have a hard time getting pitching there. They gave up a lot to go all-in, so I applaud the effort. But I'm still shocked." Finally, an American League general manager said he likes the deal for both clubs. "I don't get all the online angst towards Kansas City," said the GM. "I am a Shields fan. I also respect that Tampa does their homework." 一位國聯GM: 兩邊都很大膽 比較喜歡皇家 一位美聯人士: 比較喜歡皇家 Myers可能名不副實 兩位國聯人士: 皇家被搶了 光芒得到很多年輕肉體 Moore會玩開心農場 可是被偷很多菜 一位美聯GM: 雙贏 我是Shields粉 -- ◆ From: 140.109.64.209
※ 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/MLB/M.1355220434.A.5FA.html

推 brosucks:"我是Shields粉" XDDD 12/11 18:09

推 karta328: 絲 12/11 18:12

推 kucat: Shields fan 12/11 18:13

推 vg175:被偷菜XD 神比喻 12/11 18:18

推 goopa:第二段那兩位國聯的GM其中一位也說可以理解皇家的賭博 12/11 18:20

→ goopa:如果光看這篇，其實跟版上的反應算是頗有差距... 12/11 18:21

→ ethanluo:關鍵就在Myers，打得出預期成績，就是光芒賺到了! 12/11 18:53

推 x147159357:鄉民只是球迷，他們可是實際操盤者(不過作的好不好就.. 12/11 19:27

→ uranusjr:不只是板上的反應, 全世界的鄉民眾幾乎都同意光芒搶很大 12/11 21:19

→ uranusjr:這個交易的棒球界/鄉民眾觀點落差不下今年的 MVP 爭奪戰 12/11 21:20

推 burdette:光芒這樣可以繼續讓他們的SP維持30歲以下嗎? 12/11 21:36

推 immortalqq:可以啊 光芒農場比較不缺投手新秀 砲手很缺 12/11 21:49

→ yslin6:Happy farm被偷菜XD 12/11 22:02

→ abc12812:問題就只有一個: Shields是Ace嗎? 好像很多球團人員認為 12/11 22:14

→ abc12812:是 不得不說這某種程度上是一種east coast bias 12/11 22:15

推 Lasvegas:開心農場的比喻好妙 XDDDD 12/11 22:16

→ abc12812:數據打開看 Shields到底有多少料一目瞭然 12/11 22:16

推 burdette:比較像是那種老大型的 因為SP當中他年齡最長 12/11 22:16

→ abc12812:標準的一天到晚說低估 低估到全世界都知道他被低估的高估 12/11 22:17

推 alex710707:他就不錯 但不是ACE 再怎樣護航都改變不了事實 12/11 22:25

推 Seele11:11年以前說Shields不是Ace還沒話說 但這兩年他的表現就是A 12/11 22:46

→ Seele11:Ace水準 12/11 22:47

→ abc12812:這兩年的ERA+總合 Shields還排不進前20名 12/11 22:50

→ abc12812:WAR排17 和IPK/Buehrle同等級 這樣很ace嗎? 12/11 22:51

推 Seele11:要比生涯的話個人認為盾會比較可能像Cliff lee而非Hallada 12/11 22:53

→ Seele11:y 12/11 22:53

→ william80730:在夜釣嗎? 12/12 00:19

推 mess0706:MLB才三十隊，甚至有些球隊會有兩支以上的ACE 12/12 00:29

→ mess0706:所以排十七不夠ACE嗎？要不要定義一下甚麼叫ACE呢 12/12 00:29

→ mess0706:我覺得IPK，Buehrle，盾哥，去皇家都可以當ACE啊 12/12 00:30

推 x147159357:Ace不Ace他說了算阿!! 我們哪裡有講話的餘地 12/12 01:00

→ uranusjr:是不是 ace 根本不重要, 唯一重要的是他不值得用 Myers 12/12 02:14

→ uranusjr:換; 這交易讓我想起當年經典的 Kazmir <-> Zambrano 12/12 02:15

→ uranusjr:不過雙方出的價值都更高, 皇家冒的風險比當年大都會更大 12/12 02:16

推 nolander:夜釣XD 噴飯了XD 12/12 04:36

→ jordandaren:應該是美聯東區太強了!!光芒下季已經放棄了 12/13 16:03

→ jordandaren:把目標放在未來了 12/13 16:04

→ Kcarpenter:光芒先發還有價格 尼曼 Moore 海利克森 放棄??? 12/15 12:48